Case Study: The Unbroken Queen by Terina Adams

Catching the attention of readers in a crowded genre

Terina Adams, author of The Unbroken Queen, thought NetGalley was just for traditional publishers. She was pleasantly surprised to find a Romantasy audience eager for her books, and a new social media following who are now excited for the next book in her  series. 

In this case study, Adams shares her writing routine, the impact and importance of social media, and how NetGalley has helped The Unbroken Queen succeed in ways Adams could not have predicted.

Romantasy is a very popular genre right now! Did you always think that would be the direction you would take your writing?

I’m a very eclectic reader and have already written in four different genres under various pen names, so I’ll likely find my muse leading me to new genres in the future. I write for my enjoyment as well as for my readers, and I find it difficult to confine myself to just one genre. Currently, I’m thoroughly enjoying the romantasy genre and plan to stay here for a while—I already have another series planned and ready to begin.

Talk us through what a typical day of writing looks like for you. 

I’m envious of all those morning people because that’s just not me. I love the idea of starting my day super early and finishing earlier, but my brain doesn’t function optimally first thing in the morning. My workday typically starts around 9:00 AM, after I’ve made my daily pilgrimage to the local coffee van and walked the dog. I usually warm up by re-reading the previous chapter. I used to write in one-hour blocks, taking at least a 10-minute break in between to move and stretch. However, I’ve recently purchased an under-the-desk treadmill, which has been fantastic. I can now work continuously until lunch. In the afternoon, I write for a few more hours and handle emails and the business side of writing. Depending on how my day goes, I usually wrap up around 4:00 PM and either go for a jog or walk the dog again.

How has social media impacted / influenced you as both a writer and a marketer? 

Social media is definitely a weak point for me—it’s never been something I particularly enjoy, and so I have had to work at it. However, it can be an author’s best friend and a fantastic way to connect with readers. Gone are the days when authors were hidden behind a wall and readers had to send letters to publishers in the hope they may receive a reply from their favorite author. Social media allows authors to be real, personable, and foster direct relationships with their audience. It also has revolutionized book sales. Platforms like Bookstagram and BookTok have become essential hubs for avid readers to share recommendations and discover new books. These sites are invaluable for authors to stay in touch with trending tropes and understand what readers are looking for. Marketing on social media has taught me how to distill the core essence of my book into concise phrases, catchy memes, and enticing hooks. It’s a great way for authors to peel back the layers and get to the heart of describing their books.

I appreciate the extended availability period for my book and the diverse readership it reaches. NetGalley has helped me connect with readers I might not have been able to reach otherwise.

This is your first experience using NetGalley. What drew you to using our services for The Unbroken Queen?

I’m always looking for new ways to market my books, and one strategy I use is to get my book into as many readers’ hands as possible before release. I’ve experimented with different platforms and initially thought NetGalley was mainly for traditional publishers. However, once I explored it further, I was excited by the opportunities it offered. I appreciate the extended availability period for my book and the diverse readership it reaches. NetGalley has helped me connect with readers I might not have been able to reach otherwise.

Toni Morrison on rewriting says, “The revision for me is the exciting part; it’s the part that I can’t wait for—getting the whole dumb thing done so that I can do the real work, which is making it better and better and better.” Did you use any of the feedback or conversations you had from listing your book on NetGalley as an impetus to edit? 

No, I didn’t. Most of the feedback I received from reviewers was based more on personal preferences rather than structural, plot, or character issues. As an author, it’s important to remember not to edit by committee. I rely on my developmental editor and a few trusted beta readers to prepare my book for publication. I would consider revising details if I saw recurring reviews mentioning significant issues, such as confusion about the plot, major plot holes, or errors. If there’s a recurring theme in their preferences, I might take that into account when starting another series.

What is your general rewriting process like from the time you start sharing your book with reviewers to when it’s in publication? 

My rewriting process isn’t particularly lengthy because I do a lot of editing as I write. I also work with a developmental editor who helps address major structural, plot, and character issues. After that, I share the manuscript with trusted beta readers in my genre, who help fine-tune it. By the time the book reaches reviewers, I’ve already gone over it multiple times. If I notice recurring critiques from reviewers, I’ll make minor tweaks, but I usually leave the book as it is. However, I may take those critiques into consideration for my next series, especially if I believe they can help me craft a more compelling story. It’s important to remember you can’t write a book that pleases everyone.

Writing can be a lonely process, how has using NetGalley helped you build a community for your most recent book and how can you leverage that community for your forthcoming book?

NetGalley has been fantastic for building a community around my books. I’ve connected with Bookstagrammers I wouldn’t have reached otherwise, thanks to the platform’s extensive user base. With the second book in the series being released this month, NetGalley has provided me with a list of enthusiastic Bookstagrammers eager to review and feature it. It’s been an invaluable resource for expanding my reach and engaging with passionate readers.

The most crucial aspect of any book’s success is how well you market it to your target audience.

With over 4,000 Impressions, 500+ Members with Access, and more than 130 Members (and counting!) who have left Feedback, your book has gained a lot of traction since listing it in our catalog in March. What do you think makes your book stand out to readers?  

Honestly, I’m not entirely sure, but it certainly helps that romantasy is a popular genre right now, with many readers actively seeking books in this category. However, the most crucial aspect of any book’s success is how well you market it to your target audience. First impressions matter, so your cover should be clear and genre-specific. It should stand out while still aligning with the visual expectations of the genre. Once you’ve caught the attention of your ideal reader with the cover, the blurb must then convince them the story inside is exactly what they’re looking for. It’s also beneficial to understand your genre conventions, and you’ll earn extra points if you’re familiar with beloved tropes within the genre. Knowing these elements can help you better meet readers’ expectations and enhance your book’s appeal.

Which specific features of NetGalley have felt the most exciting to you as you ushered your book into the world? 

The NetGalley feature I loved the most was the promotions, which significantly boosted the visibility of my book after the initial excitement from its listing started to fade. The reports feature was also great, providing valuable insights into how readers were perceiving and receiving my book. It was fantastic to see positive responses to my cover and blurb, as they are crucial in shaping readers’ interest and expectations, and it was reassuring to know I got those right. I also enjoyed seeing how many people indicated they would recommend my book to others.

Where is the most value you have found in using NetGalley as a tool for The Unbroken Queen?

The most valuable aspect of using NetGalley for me has been connecting with Bookstagrammers and BookTokers. Book marketing often involves extensive outreach, and while you can DM book influencers and anyone on social media interested in books, it requires a lot of research to find the right people for your genre, and there’s no guarantee on how long their TBR list might be. NetGalley, however, provides access to a large list of avid readers already searching for their next read. I was thrilled to see how many people shared my book on their social media pages, sparking a lot of conversation around it.

With the archive date for your book in the fall, what do you hope to achieve on NetGalley in the next few months?

I’ve been very pleased with the results from NetGalley so far. I continue to receive requests, and I’m happy to let the process run its course until the archive date.

NetGalley has been the perfect complement to my other marketing efforts, helping to expand my book’s reach and visibility.

What are the takeaways you have gained from your experience using NetGalley and how will they impact marketing your forthcoming book, The Reluctant Queen?

I will definitely use NetGalley again. It’s an excellent way to reach a diverse range of readers effortlessly. The key is to build buzz around your book before its release, gathering a group of enthusiastic fans who are excited to discuss your book and share it with others. NetGalley has been the perfect complement to my other marketing efforts, helping to expand my book’s reach and visibility. Thanks to NetGalley, I have a list of Bookstagrammers and BookTokers who are keen to help me spread the buzz about the second in my series The Reluctant Queen.

Divider

Focus On: LGBTQIAP+

Happy Pride! NetGalley offers a wealth of insightful data that sheds light on the latest trends and preferences, and we’re thrilled to focus on the LGBTQIAP+ category this month. If you haven’t browsed this categories recently, you may be missing out! In the past 12 months, publishers have added over 950 new books, generating a lot of engagement and excitement from the NetGalley community.

Download the full report here.

Read on for a glimpse at some of the Most Requested and Top Performing books in the LGBTQIAP+ category

Most Requested*

On average, books in this category receive about 317 requests and auto-approvals. This includes activity generated when a publisher invites a reader to access the book using the NetGalley widget or makes the book available to ‘Read Now’, in addition to organic requests from NetGalley members. The Feedback Ratio (amount of Feedback returned based on all types of approval) is 34%.

Most requested status changes regularly. Books listed in this article were among the most requested in June 2024.

Top Performing**

** “Top Performers” refers to the amount of Feedback titles received. Books listed in this article were among the Top Performers in May 2024.

Case Study: Vengeance Planning for Amateurs by Lee Winter

Penguins, plotting, and payback? Yes please! This cover was love at first sight for the NetGalley team, but it was the “offbeat elements” and “cast of colorful characters” that had NetGalley members hooked. Here’s more of what readers thought about  Vengeance Planning for Amateurs:

  • 96 Feedback as of May 29, 2024
  • Average 4.4 star rating
  • 95% of approved reviewers would recommend this book/author to their audience
  • Over 100 thumbs up on the cover!
  • Check out other books from Ylva Publishing here!

Promotions for LGBTQIAP+

Launch your frontlist or leverage your backlist! We have both on-site and email promotions for every budget, goal, and type of book. Learn more or view the full Media Kit here.

This newsletter was sent to 36,500 members who are interested in LGBTQIAP+ books, and saw a 39% open rate!

Information in this article is from May 2024unless otherwise specified. Data includes details from NetGalley.com.

Divider

Focus On: Indie Reads

NetGalley offers a wealth of insightful data that sheds light on the latest trends and preferences, and we’re thrilled to focus on Independent Books & Publishers this month. If you haven’t browsed these categories recently, you may be missing out! In 2023, indie publishers added nearly 2,500 new books, generating a lot of engagement and excitement from the NetGalley community.

Read on for a glimpse at some of the Most Requested and Top Performing Indie Reads

Most Requested* Indie Reads

On average, books by independent publishers receive about 280 requests and auto-approvals. This includes activity generated when a publisher invites a reader to access the book using the NetGalley widget or makes the book available to ‘Read Now’, in addition to organic requests from NetGalley members. The Feedback Ratio (amount of Feedback returned based on all types of approval) is 24%.

Most requested status changes regularly. Books listed in this article were among the most requested on December 2023.

Top Performing** Indie Reads

** “Top Performers” refers to the amount of Feedback titles received. Books listed in this article were among the Top Performers in December 2023.

Case Study: Every Day is Christmas by Karen Schaler

A beloved name in Christmas romance, Karen Schaler’s newest book is bringing joy to readers everywhere. Was Every Day is Christmas love at “frost” sight for NetGalley members too? Let’s find out! 

  • 180 Feedback as of February, 2024
  • Over 3,300 Impressions
  • 100% of approved Librarians recommend the book through Reader’s Advisory, book clubs, events.
  • 11% of all readers requested the book due to word of mouth recommendations!
  • See Karen’s previously listed books with Hawktale Publishing on NetGalley here!

Case Study: Avocado Magic by Taltal Levi

Beautiful illustrations, family sweetness, and learning about avocados– what’s not to love! NetGalley members praised Avocado Magic for being a heartwarming story about patience and believing in yourself.  

  • Love this book’s cover? We did too! Avocado Magic was featured on our Homepage for a full week!
  • 95% of approved Educators recommended their students read or purchase this book
  • 100% of Booksellers are likely to handsell this book
  • The book’s illustrations were by far the thing NetGalley members loved most about this book in their reviews
  • Check out NorthSouth Book’s other books on NetGalley here!

Case Study: So Late in the Day by Claire Keegan

From Booker Prize Finalist and bestselling author of Small Things Like These, NetGalley members called this book of short stories “succinct yet impactful” and “profound”. Here’s what NetGalley members thought of So Late in the Day: 

  • 369 feedback as of February, 2024
  • Over 6,700 impressions
  • 100% of Booksellers who submitted feedback suggested they would purchase this book for their stores
  • 92% of Reviewers would recommend this book/author to their audience
  • 277 four and five star reviews were generated from NetGalley members
  • Check out Grove Atlantic’s other books  here! 

Promotions for Indie Reads

Launch your frontlist or leverage your backlist! We have both on-site and email promotions for every budget, goal, and type of book. Learn more or view the full Media Kit here.

This newsletter was sent to 25,500 members who are interested in Indie Reads, and saw a 66% open rate!

Information in this article is from December 2023unless otherwise specified. Data includes details from NetGalley.com.

Divider

Focus On: Cooking, Food & Wine

NetGalley offers a wealth of insightful data that sheds light on the latest trends and preferences, and in this holiday season we’re focusing on Cooking, Food & Wine. If you haven’t browsed these categories recently, you may be missing out! In the last 12 months, publishers have added over 270 new books, generating a lot of engagement and excitement from the NetGalley community.

Read on for a glimpse at some of the Most Requested* and Top Performing** books in these categories!

Most Requested Cooking, Food & Wine

On average, books in the Cooking, Food & Wine category receive about 158 requests and auto-approvals. This includes activity generated when a publisher invites a reader to access the book using the NetGalley widget or makes the book available to ‘Read Now’, in addition to organic requests from NetGalley members. The Feedback Ratio (amount of Feedback returned based on all types of approval) is 24%.

Most requested status changes regularly. Books listed in this article were among the most requested on November 27, 2023.

Top Performing Cooking, Food & Wine

** “Top Performers” refers to the amount of Feedback titles received. Books listed in this article were among the Top Performers in September 2023.

Case Study: Wine Witch on Fire by Natalie MacLean

Hailed as a heartfelt and inspiring journey, Dundurn Press promoted what would become a National Bestseller on NetGalley pre-publication. Here’s what NetGalley members toast to about Wine Witch on Fire

  • 90 feedback as of November 2023
  • Nearly 1,600 impressions
  • 80% of Media/Journalists said they are interested in the author for interviews/events
  • 96% of Reviewers would recommend this book/author to their audience
  • 81 four and five star reviews on NetGalley

Buzz Beyond NetGalley

Promotions for Cooking, Food & Wine

Launch your frontlist or leverage your backlist! We have both on-site and email promotions for every budget, goal, and type of book. Learn more or view the full Media Kit here.

This newsletter was sent to over 24,200 members who are interested in Cooking, Food & Wine, and saw a 39% open rate!

Information in this article is from September 2023unless otherwise specified. Data includes details from NetGalley.com.

Divider

Focus On: Mystery & Thrillers, Horror, and True Crime

NetGalley offers a wealth of insightful data that sheds light on the latest trends and preferences, and in this spooky season we’re focusing on Mystery & Thrillers, Horror, and True Crime. If you haven’t browsed these categories recently, you may be missing out! In the last 12 months, publishers have added nearly 5,000 new books, generating a lot of engagement and excitement from the NetGalley community.

Read on for a glimpse at some of the Most Requested* and Top Performing** books in these categories!

Most Requested Mystery & Thrillers

On average, books in the Mystery & Thriller category receive about 320 requests and auto-approvals. This includes activity generated when a publisher invites a reader to access the book using the NetGalley widget or makes the book available to ‘Read Now’, in addition to organic requests from NetGalley members. The Feedback Ratio (amount of Feedback returned based on all types of approval) is 29%.

Most requested status changes regularly. Books listed in this article were among the most requested on October 27, 2023.

Top Performing Mystery & Thrillers

** “Top Performers” refers to the amount of Feedback titles received. Books listed in this article were among the Top Performers in October 2023.

Most Requested Horror

Most requested status changes regularly. Books listed in this article were among the most requested on October 27, 2023.

Top Performing Horror

** “Top Performers” refers to the amount of Feedback titles received. Books listed in this article were among the Top Performers in October 2023.

Most Requested True Crime

Most requested status changes regularly. Books listed in this article were among the most requested on October 27, 2023.

Top Performing True Crime

** “Top Performers” refers to the amount of Feedback titles received. Books listed in this article were among the Top Performers in October 2023.

Case Study: The Ballad of Old Joe Booth

by William Pauley III

Horror meets poetry, this Doom Fiction audiobook has NetGalley members atwitter with four and five star reviews. Here’s how The Ballad of Old Joe Booth has made some spooky waves:

– 89 feedback as of October 23, 2023

– Over 2,000 impressions

– 100% of approved Booksellers nominated this book for the Indie Next List

– 95% of Reviewers would recommend this book/author to their audience

– The word “recommend” was in the top list of words used in NetGalley reviews! 

View this book on NetGalley!

Buzz Beyond NetGalley!

Note: The cover of this book was updated since these reviews were written.

Promotions for Mystery & Thrillers, Horror, and True Crime

Launch your frontlist or leverage your backlist! We have both on-site and email promotions for every budget, goal, and type of book. Learn more or view the full Media Kit here.

This newsletter was sent to over 38,000 members who are interested in Mysteries & Thrillers, and saw a 77% open rate!

Information in this article is from October 2023unless otherwise specified. Data includes details from NetGalley.com.

Divider

Case Study: Yes, Chef by Waitlyn Andrews

How a debut author found her fans on NetGalley

Waitlyn Andrews’ Yes, Chef received nearly 400 reviews in less than three months. Read on to hear her journey from writing 3,000 words per day, to learning about book-specific marketing and engaging with her reviewers—even going so far as to change the ending of the book!

Your debut romantic comedy, Yes, Chef, was self-published August 3rd, 2023. What role did NetGalley play in your early promotion of this book?

NetGalley has been my favorite pre-launch promotion tool, so I’m happy to gush all about it. I did a little research on YouTube to find best practice advice from other authors, and in the process found a lot of native content by NetGalley explaining the whole thing! I was several videos deep and convinced I needed to try it out.

Since this is my debut, I started from ground zero. I knew in order to build an audience from scratch, I had to invest in intentional marketing. My day job is in the digital marketing world, but the book world is a whole new industry, so I had a lot to learn. I make most of my personal reading choices based on reviews and ratings, so I chose that as the most important social proof to invest in pre-launch. I went from zero people knowing about my book to an email list of 1,300+ all because of NetGalley, and I’m not even mad about having to upgrade my free mailchimp account because of it!

I went from zero people knowing about my book to an email list of 1,300+ all because of NetGalley, and I’m not even mad about having to upgrade my free mailchimp account because of it!

Yes, Chef is described as “an upbeat, closed-door sizzling-with-chemistry, romantic comedy that will have you believing in the magic of a 90’s Rom-Com again.” What about ’90s rom-coms appeals to you? How do they influence your work?

There’s an inherent optimism in 90’s rom coms that I wanted to dwell in. It’s not that they’re without drama, but I grew up on the idea of strong female leads in occupations that I wanted falling in love with the right guys who support them in that journey.

I’m a huge, huge Nancy Meyers junkie, and one of the things she does best in her movies is plant the audience in a lifestyle so immersively that you become a mini expert in random fields and locations, so much so that you find yourself suddenly wanting to wear only linen or become a wedding dress designer, and I attribute that to her attention to detail in the setting. Based on the reviews I received from NetGalley readers, that seemed to be the case in Yes, Chef. Those were definitely my favorite reviews to read because it means that those readers got it, and those are my people!

Yes, Chef saw thousands of impressions on NetGalley, even before your planned Featured Title promotion. To what do you attribute this immediate success?

Based on the stats (which my husband and I watched like hawks because it was all so exciting) the top two reasons people selected the book were the cover and the blurb. And can I just say, that was a MAJOR sigh of relief on both accounts!

I dabble in illustration, but I know my own limits and when my version of the cover somehow included comically over-proportioned cheesy chef hats and hands that looked nothing like hands, I knew I needed to hire it out. The cover artist I worked with was a gem and she took my talking points and RAN with them. The result is something that I frequently just sit and stare at in disbelief.

As for the blurb, I went a little against the grain in the standard back-cover description, but I felt like the internal dialogue that happens in a single-POV book can quickly introduce the readers to the writing style and thought process of the character they’re about to invest their time in. Apparently it resonated well because it received high stats across the board. That had me grinning from ear-to-ear for weeks. I can get away with a lot because I’m in the indie space, but that also means I don’t have a sounding board to run these things by (other than my sweet, patient, husband and my kind, kind editor who answered my midnight emails). NetGalley ended up being the vote of the people and becoming that sounding board for me, so those early impressions validated a lot of the risks I took.

NetGalley ended up being the vote of the people and becoming a sounding board for me, so those early impressions validated a lot of the risks I took.

As of this writing, 18 out of 21 Librarians who have submitted Opinions on NetGalley indicated they would order Yes, Chef for their library! In your experience, in addition to Reviews, how do NetGalley members’ Opinions help you as an author?

Each category of opinion helped tell me a different story from a different perspective. The reviews helped me look critically at the content of the book based on people’s personal preferences. But, the opinions from Librarians helped me get a pulse on the perception of the book from people who are professionally in the space, and what they know from their experience with library patrons. Ultimately, getting the Opinion of one Librarian felt like getting a rating from 100+ reviewers all in one. Seeing the 18/21 result net so far beyond the positive spectrum of what I expected, I was genuinely shocked for this debut. I very much expected to be in a niche category, so I prepared myself for niche stats, but those Librarian stats exceeded my expectations.

I hear you have history with the prolific author Marie Force! Could you tell our audience a bit about that?

Oh, she’s the best! I’ve grown up watching her lifestyle and author journey on social media (she hosted my baby shower for my parents, so when I say my whole life, I mean it!) and I’ve always thought being an author was the ultimate occupation. She’s also an educator and ring-leader in the space, so her content frequently has an educational element that I’ve been gobbling up for years.

She came down to visit my parents a few years ago and we all went to dinner. She talked about her 3,000 words a day rule, and I thought surely I could try that. But the post that ultimately got me started was her recounting what her dad said to prompt her to start writing herself: She had two young kids and wanted to start her first novel but felt she didn’t have the time. Her dad asked her, “Well, what are you doing between the hours of 12pm-2am?” Now, with small kids of my own, I get it. My kids are in-and-out awake anyways, so why not start now?

Yes, Chef was born in those hours, and the sum of 3,000+ words a day eventually added up to a book, just like she said! When I told her I published a book she was wildly supportive, and having someone to watch do the actual thing throughout my life made me feel like I could jump in and try it out myself.

You’re a savvy social media marketer; even just glancing through your Instagram and TikTok, that much is apparent! What are some of your strategies for using social media to engage your audience? What have you learned works best for you and your book?

Thank you! I’ve worked in the digital marketing space for almost ten years now, but as I mentioned before, the book industry is a whole new world, even in the social space! I have general best practices I like to follow, but for my author account I just decided to have a little fun with it. In my day job, I follow the consistency rule (I could spend way too many words elaborating here but ultimately “consistency > creativity” works for most companies) but for my author account, I decided to only speak when I had something to say, and use it as a place to show readers the settings they can expect to read about because I’ve been to them, insight in the the writing process, and then pepper in book promotion content. And my cat. He’s kind of the star of the show. I think I’ve only posted the cover of my book 11/90 posts and that is NOT what I’d ever recommend in any other company or brand, but it’s been fun for me to be much more fluid and organic in my author space.

But the place I’ve loved being a little more strategic is in Reels and TikToks. I have an embarrassing amount of short-form videos from other authors saved on my personal accounts. These stack up to be my own personal TBR list. Making my own version of those videos has been so fun. Those videos always seem to spike my Kindle Unlimited reads so I’ve taken the reviews from NetGalley readers who talked about their favorite book moments and turned those into short-form videos to share on both platforms.

What was an unexpected takeaway from your experience publishing your debut novel?

There were so many unexpected moments for me, but what really got me were the social shares from NetGalley readers! I expected reviews translating to GoodReads and my Amazon page, but seeing my book out “in the wild” on social media floored me! I’d squeal every time I saw one come in, and WAY more came in than I ever expected.

I had a feeling diving all-in to NetGalley would be the best way to grow from zero, and it surpassed all my expectations.

I had a feeling diving all-in to NetGalley would be the best way to grow from zero, and it surpassed all my expectations.

When your Featured Title Promotion ran the week of August 7th, Yes, Chef enjoyed dozens of requests each day. How impactful was this NetGalley Promotion for you and Yes, Chef?

The promotion was crucial in getting my book in an above-the-fold location. The timing of the promotions couldn’t have been better. It ran a week after my public launch and about a month after my original NetGalley launch, and my requests nearly 5x-ed daily for the week of the promotion.

The above-the-fold space also put me on the same landing page as some better-known authors with similar cover styles. So for a week I had the pleasure of seeing my book on the same page with “some of the greats,” as I’d put it, and that type of proximity was extremely helpful to getting adjacent author audiences aware of my book. Did I screenshot the page every time my book landed somewhere near an author I obsess over? Yes, yes I did.

For a week I had the pleasure of seeing my book on the same page with “some of the greats,” as I’d put it, and that type of proximity was extremely helpful to getting adjacent author audiences aware of my book.

What is one piece of advice you would offer to your fellow self-published authors using NetGalley?

I would say go all in with it! Take special note of the cover and the blurb. Since I found such success in those two elements I will definitely pay close attention to those for the next books I make available on NetGalley.

And then since I’m a chronic word vomiter (occupational hazard, I guess) I’ll offer the second piece of advice: Do not be afraid to be firm in your writing style while also paying attention to criticism that could ultimately be helpful.

I wrote a ridiculous happy ending. I knew it was a swept-up, tie-all-the-loose strings, leave-no-room-for-doubt kind of happy ending and that’s a writing style that I greatly enjoy because illogical third-act-breakups make me want to hurl my e-reader across the room (lovingly). That’s my writing style, and it’s a polarizing style, but I know there’s a niche of people like me out there that use books for escapism, and happy places are the nicest places to escape to. But I did notice that about 30% of the reviews that came in said the ending felt rushed. At first I thought, well, that’s just me! That’s how I’ll write! And then I marinated on it a little bit more and realized the people just wanted a bit more and, really, if that’s a criticism I’m working with, why not adjust? Before launching the book to the public I ended up adding two more chapters and about 12,000 more words because one of the best things I can take away from so many reviews is an open mind and ability to think critically about what’s being asked of me while not changing the foundation of what I create. When I emailed all of my reviewers that I’d updated the book with more content, I got an overwhelming amount of support (even from those who didn’t think it was rushed!) and at the end of the day I feel closer to my readers for understanding what they want and then acting on it.

I realized the people just wanted a bit more and, really, if that’s a criticism I’m working with, why not adjust? … At the end of the day I feel closer to my readers.

 What’s next for you? What do Wailtyn Andrews and Yes, Chef fans have to look forward to?

One of the reasons it took me so long to get into writing in the first place was the disbelief in my ability to think of scenarios, people and contexts different enough to produce more than one book. But once I opened that dam, things started flowing.

The next book on the horizon is about half way done. It’s a cowboy romance that my husband already says is his favorite (he says that about every book). My parents grew up in Northern Colorado, cowboy country, and my whole life I’ve grown up adjacent to the culture, so this has been a fun genre to work in.

Within the Yes, Chef world, Lucy is actually next up! Her MMC (male main character) is exciting for me because their meet-ugly will be the altered-just-enough-to-be-fiction version of the way I met my husband. Let’s just say he had to work hard to convince me he was actually interested in dating, and Lucy’s MMC will have quite the fun hill to climb.

After that I’ve got a few others in the works (like Evie and Gabe, I promise they’re coming!) but pacing-wise I think I’ll launch about two books a year—with a very large caveat that this year we have another member of our family joining in January, and he will likely be very demanding and require lots of attention if he’s like our first two kids.

Waitlyn Andrews is a pen name author who created an entire personality niched in the idea of fully diving into every reading-loving trope there is, unapologetically. Her books are built on the foundation that reading should be an escape that you walk away from having learned empathy for someone’s way of life and an inherent belief in the optimism of making your own life better.

Divider